Top Ten List of What Microsoft Doesn't Want You to Know About IntranetWare

Novell

September 1996



Response to Microsoft's Windows NT Server / IntranetWare Feature Comparison

#1 Upgrading to IntranetWare

IntranetWare is Novell's comprehensive platform for a full-service intranet. Built on the foundation of Novell's industry-leading NetWare® 4 network services engine, IntranetWare provides both IP and IPX access to intranet resources such as Web servers, FTP servers and WAN connections to the Internet. IntranetWare lets you use your existing network infrastructure to make your networks do more for your business.

What MS Wants You to Believe

IntranetWare contains a limited set of new features that represent nothing more than a maintenance upgrade to NetWare 4.1 and is not enough to motivate businesses to upgrade.

IntranetWare Facts

IntranetWare provides a complete intranetware/Internet solution: Web server, Internet connectivity, Netscape browser, IPX-to-IP gateway, multiprotocol routing, wide area connectivity and tools for creating intranet applications and as well as the core network services required by an intranet--directory, security, file, print, messaging and management. No other network solution provides a comparable package of intranet services.

What Others Say

"Finally, Novell revealed that its next version of NetWare, dubbed Green River, will carry the 4.11 version number -- a .01 upgrade from the current 4.1. Even so, it appears to offer more of an increase than Windows NT 4.0 does over 3.51 -- but then Microsoft was never very good with numbering systems." Network World, June 17, 1996 (page 31)

#2 A Suitable Applications Platform

IntranetWare provides a high-performance application engine that excels with large database and Internet applications. Novell partners provide application solutions for large database, web servers, and data management and migration powered by NetWare that can't be equaled on NT. Using the power of NDS, application servers and users can be accessed and managed from a common interface, security mechanism and user database.

What MS Wants You to Believe

IntranetWare is not a reliable applications platform. You will have to deploy, manage, and integrate a separate applications platform in your intranet environment.

IntranetWare Facts

IntranetWare is reliable, supports thousands of applications, and integrates existing or new application servers.

More network professionals sell, support, develop and conform to Novell networks solutions than to any other network platform. More than 20,000 reseller partners worldwide sell Novell network solutions, and over 6,000 applications have been written for Novell networking platforms. More than 200,000 certified professionals support NetWare around the globe, with 125,000 candidates in the certification process. Approximately 5,000 certified professionals currently support Microsoft Windows NT.

What Others Say

"There is no denying that 3-year-old Windows NT Server has far fewer third-party applications than its more mature rival NetWare. There are fewer than a dozen third-party packages shipping for Microsoft Corp.'s Windows NT Server, compared with thousands for Novell, Inc.'s NetWare." Computerworld, March 11, 1996

"The most prevalent software running on networked computers is common, off-the-shelf business applications such as word processors, spreadsheets, simple databases, and E-mail. Although the applications may be located on the client, most of the applications' output resides on the server.

"The important requirements are file and print performance, easy administration, inexpensive and efficient hardware, and interoperability. In all these areas, NetWare is hard to beat.

"Currently, most complex database applications include one of several high-end solutions from vendors such as Oracle Corp., Sybase Inc., IBM, and Lotus Development Corp. -- using SQL or proprietary development tools and a variety of front ends. These solutions work across existing networks, running with special versions of the database engine on various platforms. And because of the tight integration that database vendors have achieved with it, NetWare can provide these database engines with performance that Windows NT can't approach." LAN Times, May 13, 1996

#3 Ease of Installation

IntranetWare offers an installation process that automatically detects hardware such as LAN and disk adapters and automatically installs the appropriate drivers and protocol configurations.

What MS Wants You to Believe

NT Server 4.0 is the "plug and play" intranet server.

IntranetWare Facts

IntranetWare reduces a barrier for smaller shops who don't have a CNE or don't have any experience on NetWare. IntranetWare will basically install itself now. In addition, products such as Symmetric Multiprocessing and NetWare/IP, which used to be installed separately, are now installed in the same process.

What Others Say

"There are now about 3,000 hardware devices on the market that meet plug-and-play specs, according to Microsoft. Which makes one curious why plug-and-play still isn't in NT." ClieNT Server News, June 10-14, 1996 (page 6)

"'The installation routine was very straightforward and very clean,' said Tony Najera, senior systems engineer for Kissane Business Systems, an Addison, Ill., reseller. In a recent experience, he installed [IntranetWare, which had been code-named Green River] both directly on a server with a CD-ROM drive, and indirectly on another server, which didn't have its own CD-ROM drive, through the first server. I haven't encountered any Green River installations where it stalled, or didn't finish or blew up,' he said. Some of the earlier versions of NetWare, four or five years ago, gave me those problems, but this one seems to be pretty straightforward.' Communications Week Interactive, July 26, 1996

#4 Web Server and NetWork Performance

IntranetWare was designed for leanness and performance. The specialized design of IntranetWare provides superior performance when handling network traffic, web services, databases and applications that have been written to IntranetWare.

What MS Wants You to Believe

Microsoft claims to have "the fastest Web server for Windows NT Server." They want customers to believe that their network and Web server performance is superior to their competition.

IntranetWare Facts

According to Shiloh Consulting, the NetWare Web Server is the fastest Intel-based Web server available, beating out both Microsoft's and Netscape's Web servers.

The NetWare Web Server which is included with IntranetWare is the only Web server in the industry that is integrated with a directory. This means you can search information in the NDS directory tree using any standard web browser, and you can easily publish directory information on your intranet or even on the Internet.

What Others Say

"'It looks real good,' said Jim Pappas a network specialist at WHDH-TV in Boston. We wanted a straightforward, uncomplicated approach to building a corporate intranet that can also let our end users easily access the Internet. Deploying NDS in conjunction with the NetWare Web Server will let us use one set of user log-ins for all our applications.'

"'We estimate it will halve administration and configuration time,' Pappas added.

"The speed and integration that comes with NDS are powerful lures. Several users -- including some who use Microsoft Corp.'s Windows NT Internet Information Server (IIS) in mixed environments -- said they may consider switching to the NetWare Web Server.

"'The ties to NDS and the speed eliminate my two biggest administration woes,' said Phillip Dunham, a network technician at Holmans of Nevada, a Las Vegas-based retailer. We'd be willing to displace the IIS Server because Cairo [Microsoft's enterprise directory] won't be out for a year,' Dunham said.

"Josh Turiel, director of information services at Ad Life Marketing, Inc. in Norwood, Mass. -- another mostly Windows NT Server shop -- said the sheer speed of the NetWare engine may be too good to pass up.

"NetWare is the fastest core services engine out there. And that means I don't have to worry about taking a performance hit when my users deploy the NetWare Web Server,' he said." Computerworld, August 12, 1996 (page 6)

#5 Security

Through NDS, IntranetWare provides the industry's only hierarchical security management, allowing easy control of the security access of individuals, groups or the entire organization from a single administrative interface. This includes comprehensive Internet access control to restrict use of the Internet to authorized users. RSA public key/private key technology ensures that a password never crosses the network wire in an unecrypted format.

What MS Wants You to Believe

That Windows NT Server's C2 Orange book security rating is somehow useful as a network server.

IntranetWare Facts

C2 security has become a decision point for many network buyers. NT Server is not certified as a C2 secure network. Windows NT has received C2 certification as a standalone workstation only. According to the NCSC Evaluated Products List, Windows NT hasn't yet been accepted for C2 Red Book (trusted network) consideration.

IntranetWare is the only intranet solution built for C2 "trusted network" security. Windows NT is C2 certified as a standalone workstation only--with no network adapter, floppy disk drive or modem installed--and not as a server operating system.

What Others Say

"When one administrator is creating user accounts and assigning them privileges that can't be seen by the administrator of another master domain, 'you've lost control of your system,' asserts Robert Harbison, president of Network Integration Consultants, a network design firm in Sausilito, Calif. "If you want strong, centralized administration and close-knit groups, then NT will make you 'sweat bullets' as you try to design an accessible but secure network, in the words of one security manager in San Francisco. "NT lags behind Novell's NetWare in this respect. NetWare 4.1's global directory lets an administrator implement security in a straightforward manner. In addition, it's scalable across many NetWare networks." Computerworld, June 3, 1996 (page 126)

"It's probably a shock to those who believe Microsoft's marketing hype to find out Windows NT Server is actually both slow and does not meet C2 level security in a network environment. But that isn't the issue. The real issue is that a publication allowed its perception of external pressure keep valuable information from its readers" Communications Week, May 13, 1996 (page 74)

#6 New Features

IntranetWare gives you all the services of a full-service intranet platform--file, print, directory, messaging, Web publishing, security, connectivity and management. It includes high-performance Web and FTP servers and all the software you need to give users on your network access to the Web and other popular TCP-based intranet and Internet services.

What MS Wants You to Believe

There is little to no new intranet functionality in IntranetWare.

IntranetWare Facts

With IntranetWare you can extend your existing Novell IPX network to meet your evolving needs--including access to the Internet and corporate intranet. There's no need to rip and replace. This means you can leverage your existing investment in equipment and training.

New IntranetWare features (not included in earlier versions of NetWare) include the following;

NetWare v2.5 Web server, NetBasic tool for creating intranet applications, TCP/IP with DHCP support, IP/IPX gateway, Multiprotocol routing, Internet Service Provider connectivity, Netscape browser, Java platform, Symmetric Multiprocessing (SMP), Hardware autodetection, Automated choice and configuration of protocols, NDS modeling with DS Migrate utility, NetWare File Migration utility, Abend Recovery, NDS Manager, improved GUI administration, and eligiblility for C2 compliant network security.

What Others Say

"IntranetWare is Novell, Inc.'s new flagship, and it represents an evolution of the NetWare product line. This release, developed in beta as Green River, offers a host of enhancements to the NetWare core and bundles a number of key applications and NetWare add-ons that significantly strengthen NetWare's position against Microsoft Corp.'s Windows NT Server 4.0 as a more scalable network operating system enterprise solution." InfoWorld, September 16, 1996 (page 117)

"NT 4.0 is basically a cosmetic upgrade that adds Internet capabilities to Version 3.51. . . . The two most notable changes other than the interface are the addition of the distributed common object model -- a technology that looks interesting but has little practical impact today-and video drivers move to unprotected kernel memory. This move make sense in NT Workstation, but not in NT Server; to preserve the common driver model, Microsoft has compromised NT Server's stability for NT Workstations performance." InfoWorld, May 27, 1996 (cover)

"'Novell corrected a lot of things that were hampering the mind share of 4.1. It's no longer a big, complicated enterprise product that requires a [Certified NetWare Engineer] to install,' said Josh Turiel, director of information services at Ad Life Marketing in Norwood, Mass. . . .

"'I've been playing with Green River for months now. It's stable and a major advancement for NetWare,' said Robert Harbison, an expert user and president of Network Integration Consultants, Inc. in Sausalito, Calif. . . .

"'Green River will make it a no-brainer for most NetWare 2.x and 3.x shops or users to go ahead and upgrade to NetWare,' [Lee Doyle, an analyst at International Data Corp.] said. Green River offers users much more advanced networking capabilities than the upcoming Windows NT 4.0 release, which is due out about the same time late this summer, Harbison and Doyle said. Both are familiar with the features in that release." Computerworld, June 24, 1996 (cover)

#7 IntranetWare's Openness

IntranetWare supports Internet Protocol--with DHCP to simplify deployment of IP intranets--and offers an IPX/IP gateway to enable IPX networks to connect to IP resources. Its routing capabilities enable corporations to extend their intranets to their branch offices and to connect to the Internet via ISDN, frame relay, ATM or leased line. Add-on software from Novell enables you to make your mainframe and mid-range computers a part of your intranet, as well.

What MS Wants You to Believe

IntranetWare supports only IPX/SPX with very limited support of other protocols such as TCP/IP, Apple-Talk, and NetBIOS (NetBEUI).

IntranetWare Facts

Unlike NT Server 4.0, IntranetWare provides the additional functionality of an IPX-to-IP gateway. The IPX-to-IP gateway permits communication between an IPX client and a IntranetWare server using only TCP/IP. Windows NT Server 4.0 doesn't provide an IPX-to-IP gateway. Since the Windows NT client and NT server must use the same protocol to communicate, this may impact the design and protocol choices for an network.

IntranetWare provides comprehensive client support for DOS, Windows, Windows 95, Windows NT, Macintosh, OS/2 and UNIX workstations. Novell has also promised to make NetWare protocol-neutral, starting with the delivery of IntranetWare.

IntranetWare supports all of the standards needed for Inter/intranet publishing and access. IntranetWare completely supports all the IP protocol providing seamless connectivity to Web servers, Web browser capability, and access to HTTP and HTML files. L-CGI and R-CGI are also supported.

Novell is also open to industry standards in announcing it's support for the IETF's RFC 1777, known as the Lightweight Directory Access Protocol (LDAP).

What Others Say

"Continuing its efforts to reposition itself as a cross-platform intranet player, Novell Inc. is accelerating support for Internet protocols in its core NetWare product and introducing a scheme for NetWare to better interoperate with Windows NT.

"Adding FTP services to IntranetWare -- a package for setting up intranets that includes Netscape Communication Corp.'s Navigator Web browser and an IPX/IP gateway -- will allow users to transfer files to and from NetWare servers via the common Internet based protocol, officials said. InfoWorld, September, 16, 1996 (cover)

"While IntranetWare addresses a short-coming in Novell's Internet strategy for corporate users, the company has progressed in its effort to make its directory both cross-platform and integrated with Web technology. At its IntranetWare press briefing, Novell officials demonstrated a number of products, including the precursor to NDS running on Windows NT. Code-named Tabasco and previously referred to as Applications Server Manager, the software will let users manage NetWare and NT servers simultaneously." LAN Times, September 2, 1996 (cover)

"Microsoft fails to support LDAP.

"Over 40 companies, including Netscape, AT&T, BBN Planet, Computer Associates, Digital, Excite, Hewlett Packard, IBM Lotus, Lycos, Novell, Silicon Graphics, SunSoft and Yahoo!, announced support for the IETF's RFC 1777, known as the Lightweight Directory Access Protocol." Internetwork, June 18, 1996 (page 46)

"Novell Inc.'s initial implementation of Novell Directory Services on Windows NT will rely heavily on the Lightweight Directory Access Protocol (LDAP) to link NT applications to the directory. InfoWorld, September 16, 1996 (page 16)

"Novell's IP will help ensure greater interoperability with other systems, something often lacking in Microsoft products, Blevins says. Microsoft follows industry specs when it is convenient for them to do so and is not hesitant to move away if they feel they have a better way of doing it.' Network World, September 30, 1996 (page 51)

#8 NetWare Application Launcher (NAL)

NetWare Application LauncherTM complements your ManageWise®TM management capabilities by enabling you to deploy network applications to Windows-based desktops throughout your organization. As a result, you dramatically reduce the time and cost of administering your company's productivity tools.

What MS Wants You to Believe

NAL is a tool that offers minimal functionality with serious limitations and is not designed for Intranet use.

IntranetWare Facts

NetWare Application Launcher lets the network manager physically distribute software out to the desktop through automated installations or enables users to pull applications to their desktop by providing them with set-up programs. Users simply click on an icon to launch an application.

Because users cannot delete icons or change path information, support calls to your help desk are greatly reduced. To provide full support when needed, customers can include a support number and E-mail address with each NDS-delivered network application.

Because the applications delivered through NDS are associated with a user's network login ID, they follow the user around the network. Regardless of the login location, the user always sees the same set of network applications. This means that "campus-roaming" and remote users can always access their familiar tools to stay productive.

What Others Say

"Simplicity is key. Those who do opt for Novell's NetWare Client32 for Windows 95 will be pleasantly surprised with Novell's attention to detail. New features such as the NetWare Application Launcher (NAL) extend the use of NDS, giving Client32 for Windows 95 an integration with NetWare that Microsoft's clients can't match. NAL allows network administrators to define software applications as objects in a directory tree that can be assigned group or user rights." PC Week, April 16, 1996

#9 DNS and WINS Support

Microsoft wants customers to see this as a limit to IntranetWare. However, Novell Directory Service (NDS) goes far beyond the capabilities of WINS and Domain Naming Service (DNS).

What MS Wants You to Believe

IntranetWare is limited because it doesn't have a WINS server or an integrated DNS server.

IntranetWare Facts

To ease the complexity of tracking NetBIOS names, Microsoft introduced the Windows Internet Name Service (WINS). This type of tracking is not needed with Novell's Directory Service (NDS). Comparing WINS to a similar IntranetWare capability is impossible since IntranetWare doesn't require tracking NetBIOS names through a network.

IntranetWare also supports DNS. However, IntranetWare supports a more advanced directory structure in NDS that is hierarchical, scalable, and extensible. Domains do not have this capability.

What Others Say

"On The Server Side NT Server 4.0 lacks a robust enterprise directory service. NetWare 4.1, with its NDS component, is farther ahead than Microsoft, and the much-touted ODSI interface has still not seen the light of day. Additionally, Microsoft has not taken on the challenge of revamping its management facilities. While the Windows95 GUI interface is good, NT 4.0 uses the same utilities as NT 3.51, often forcing you to run several utilities to perform one logical task. Remote administration is another big issue that NT 4.0 has still not addressed."NetWork Computing, May 1, 1996

"NT's Domain Service provides functions very similar to NNS. The flat naming structure necessitates the creation of multiple domains for medium-to large-sized networks. The required trust relationships between these domains make the service cumbersome to set up and maintain. No object types can be added to NT beyond the five that come with the name service--users, local and global groups, computers, and printer." LAN Times, January 22, 1996 (page 65)

"IDC predicts continued strong growth for NetWare through the end of the century. Customers are finding that Novell Directory Services, a central component of NetWare 4.1, enables them to handle the management of countless resources on heterogenous systems spread around the globe. As a result, a recent IDC survey shows that NetWare 4 customers are planning to expand their installations by 258%." IOMA's Report on Managing LAN Costs, June 1996 (page 7)

#10 Network Monitoring and Management

Today's heterogeneous networks include client computers; file, application and communication servers; gateways; hubs; routers and printers. They also include applications such as databases, Web servers, groupware, E-mail and document management. Add the many people who use these resources from varying locations and you have a fairly complicated network. NetWork monitoring and management is an important consideration for our network solutions.

What MS Wants You to Believe

That Microsoft NT Server 4.0 has superior network and Web management tools over IntranetWare.

IntranetWare Facts

Novell Directory Services (NDS), based on the international X.500 standard, makes it possible to organize, categorize and name all of these resources in an easy-to-access and manage network. Its hierarchical, object-oriented name structure resembles an upside-down tree with a root or trunk at the top and branches extending below it.

What Others Say

"Directory services and domains are two different ways to deal with the problem of finding a needle in a large haystack. NetWare 4's NetWare Directory Service (NDS) does it by handing you the needle when you ask for it. NT Server uses domains, which basically tell you to look in a smaller haystack. Clearly, NT has much growing to do in this area." Byte Magazine, July 1996 (page 137)

"Windows NT 4.0 Server still lacks a real directory service and suffers from a cumbersome trusted domain model, so if you're building a large network enterprise, Novell's NetWare is a better solution." Windows Sources, August 1996 (page 56)

"Windows NT Server 4.0 is just about to hit the streets with all the momentum the Microsoft Corp. Marketing machine can muscle, but users and analysts say the product simply is not ready for prime time as an enterprise NOS.

"NT Server 4.0 is greatly improved over previous versions, but it certainly is not the be-all and end-all of network operating systems,' said Jason Perlow, a consulting engineer with New Technology Partners, Inc. In Bedford, N.H. Microsoft has still got a lot to improve on in terms of a directory service and allowing users to better manage growing networks.'" Network World, September 2, 1996 (cover)

"NDS gives Novell a lead over Microsoft in network design and administration. With NDS, a network administration can establish as many workgroups as needed, assign fine grades of privileges and enforce uniform security policies. NDS allows centralized administration. It gives a central supervisor power over other administrators.

"Under NDS, there's's always a supervisor for the supervisors, and this leads to a clear chain of command and line of accountability. Under NT, it's possible for all network administrators to be equal, with all the attendant confusion.

"If you want centralized management under NT, one of the few ways to get it is to organize the enterprise as one master domain, with all users logging in to one central server. But doing so defeats the purpose of having easy-to-maintain network segments. So NT remains a distributed -- let's say fragmented -- approach to the enterprise.

"Under NDS, a general can give marching orders. Under NT, no captain can be sure what his fellow officers are doing at any time. Until NT gets a central directory late next year, Novell has a big advantage in the marketplace."Computerworld, September 16, 1996 (page 137)

Copyright 1996